Shop Second-Hand Shoes
Recently viewed
Put your best foot forward with the footwear collection at Gem Pawnbrokers. If you’re a fashion lover, sneakerhead, or resale-savvy shopper, we have the perfect mix of iconic style and smart pricing. Every pair in our collection is authenticated by our experienced pawn shop team and evaluated for quality and wear. We only list footwear that meets our standards for comfort, appearance, and brand integrity from high-fashion heels to sought-after sneakers.
You’ll find luxury designer heels, flats, boots, and sandals. We have collectible pawn sneakers from brands like Nike, Jordan, and Converse. We have designer labels such as Christian Louboutin, Gucci, Prada, Balenciaga, and more. You can choose men’s and women’s footwear in a range of sizes and styles. We also have limited edition and vintage pieces you won’t find on retail shelves. At Gem, you can walk away with real savings and real style.
Take advantage of our layaway options so you can secure your favorite pair with flexible payments. We have nationwide shipping that’s fast, secure, and fully insured. Plus, we accept returns and refunds in case the fit or feel isn’t right.
New pairs arrive often, and many are available in limited sizes so if you see something you love, don’t wait. Browse our online pawn shop or visit one of our 20+ NYC pawn shop locations to select styles in person.
FAQs
How do you authenticate your used designer shoes and sneakers?
We use a thorough vetting process for every pair. Associates reference trusted online databases and brand materials to confirm authenticity. For certain models, we add an extra layer of verification with Entrupy.
Do your shoes come with original boxes?
Most pairs of shoes include the original box.
Are the pawn shoes new, gently worn, or refurbished?
Gem only accepts, new, barely worn or deadstock shoes.
Can I return a pair of shoes if they don’t fit properly?
Shoes are not returnable. If you’re unsure about sizing, reach out before purchasing and we’ll help you decide.